At a recent XapienXchange Philanthropy discussion, a prospect development leader described how a gift officer at a US university had been entering asks at $4.9 million to avoid its $5 million due diligence threshold. The threshold had been introduced to align scrutiny with major naming opportunities, but a proposed gift of $4.9 million could escape review.
There are good reasons to focus scrutiny on major donors. According to the Council for Advancement and Support of Education’s (CASE) latest US survey, published in April 2026, just 2% of donors accounted for 89% of funds received by participating higher education institutions in 2025. For advancement teams managing substantial prospect portfolios, financial thresholds are a consistent basis for allocating research resources. Larger commitments often involve greater institutional exposure, particularly where naming rights or prominent recognition are involved.
But the gift’s value is an imperfect indicator of reputational risk. A donation below the threshold can still involve a highly visible naming opportunity, while an unfamiliar prospect may warrant closer examination regardless of the proposed amount.
Some institutions are addressing this with policies that combine financial thresholds with other criteria. Under its revised donations policy, approved in March 2026, the University of Bristol requires preliminary screening for donations of £25,000 or more and full due diligence for those exceeding £100,000. These thresholds also apply to cumulative giving over a rolling five-year period.
Crucially, the policy requires full due diligence regardless of donation value where a gift could attract significant public interest or controversy. It identifies unsolicited approaches from previously unknown donors and prospects as one circumstance that may warrant further investigation. This preserves financial thresholds as a way of prioritising research, while allowing the institution to escalate cases on reputational grounds.
When there is no gift to screen
A second US university encountered a gap of a different kind. Its fundraising due diligence policy included thresholds for anticipated asks, gifts received, and international donations. Honorary degree recipients fell outside those criteria.
Then the university awarded an honorary degree to an individual linked to an institution in South America whose positions on same-sex marriage and religion raised objections from members of the university community. According to a senior member of its research team, the controversy had not been identified before the degree was awarded. The university subsequently introduced due diligence checks for all honorary degree recipients.
The case illustrates a problem that financial thresholds cannot address: an honorary degree involves no donation, but creates a prominent and potentially lasting association with the institution.
It also highlights the need for coordination beyond advancement. Screening policies may be well established for major gifts, while other departments make decisions carrying comparable reputational implications.
Cardiff University has taken a broader approach in its due diligence policy, effective from June 2026. Its framework explicitly covers honorary degrees and fellowships, alongside donations and other institutional relationships. It assigns responsibility for due diligence to the relevant departments, with designated process owners for escalation.
This addresses an important governance question: who is responsible for identifying reputational concerns when a decision lies outside the fundraising process?
Research before the first meeting
At one US university, an advancement director based in China regularly meets prospective donors with no previous affiliation to the institution. Some express an interest in making substantial gifts, but researchers sometimes receive a name only the day before a meeting. Using Xapien, the team can return findings in around 30 minutes, helping fundraisers identify potential concerns and determine whether further investigation is needed.
This is particularly valuable for international research, where information can be scattered across jurisdictions, languages, and sources. It also changes the considerations behind screening policies. When research takes weeks, capacity limits the number of checks an institution can undertake. Faster initial assessments make broader coverage feasible, while allowing teams to concentrate more detailed investigations on cases that need them.
Reviewing the triggers
Financial thresholds remain useful for prioritising due diligence. But the experiences shared at XapienXchange Philanthropy show why institutions also need to recognise risks that fall outside them, whether that is a gift just below the threshold, an honorary degree, or a prospective donor appearing at short notice. Faster research gives teams more scope to investigate those exceptions before decisions are made.



